Sunday, May 13, 2012

Blogging 'Round: JLev and Kaytay


In response to Jacob Levin's blog entitled 'Dialectics: the Matrix'.  In a conversation between the blue pill and the red pill, he analyzes the two contrasts ideas of 'ignorance is bliss' versus 'free will'.            

Hello JLev,
I’d like to first comment on the really impressive amount of content you have in this blog.  You don’t just extrapolate on a singe aspect of the conflict between the blue pill and the red pill.  You allow one thought to connect to the next in an extremely genuine portrayal of how a mind works. Not only that, but you do it with style.  The red pill/blue pill format struck me as a simper way to accomplish the Dialectics prompt; instead of an abstract analysis of two opposing ideas, you make the ideas tangible. 
            A lot of the things you wrote sparked new ideas inside my mind.  First off, the blue pill said, “Let’s say Neo takes the red pill, becomes the One, and frees the human race.”  But wasn’t Neo the One before he decided to swallow the red pill and enter into a war torn reality?  After all, Morphius had been trying to track him down specifically.  I don’t think Morphius ever had a doubt in his mind that Neo would choose a life sans bliss for the power of controlling his own fate.  But if all that is true, doesn’t that mean the choice between the red and blue wasn’t even a choice at all, but rather Neo’s inevitable fate?  Is being controlled okay if it works out in your favor?  That may be one of the reasons why the Oracle make Neo believe he was not the chosen!  If he believed he was nothing special, and he continued to fight (which he did), his commitment to the cause would be clear.
            But as the blue pill said, the Oracle a computer program too.  Her thoughts are not real, and neither are her feelings.  If I were the red pill, I’d reply by saying, “If you were told that your feelings (love, pain, happiness, sadness) weren’t real, would you stop feelings them?”
-Julia

In response to Katy's blog entitled 'Change of Mind: Gym Class Feminists'.  Katy discovered that feminism had not played a large role in her life thus far, but it really should, considering that women not so long ago didn't have things like sports that made Katy who she is today.

Hi Katy!
            You’re opinions always seem to strike me as very honest and well thought through and this blog post is no different.  You’re right when you say that equal rights for women should simply be common sense!  I feel very blessed to live in a part of the world where it is common sense (to most, let’s not forget the places in the world where women are not so lucky).  This sounds crazy, but there have been times where I’ve romanticized feminist movements in the late 19th, early 20th centuries, wished I could’ve been part of something so blatantly worth it.  In Great Britain, suffragettes would stamp the phrase ‘VOTES FOR WOMEN’ on pennies on top of the face of King Edward XII, because they knew the coins were too low value to replace.  Isn’t that just a simply beautiful way of alerting the masses?  But now the fight for true gender equality is far more complex.  I suppose it’s because the things that are ‘common sense’ have been covered.  And what’s left isn’t such an obvious problem: equal pay in the work place, equal intellectual respect, an universal understanding that women can be powerful without being called bitches.  All of that is far too long to stamp on a coin and is invisible to many women who don’t care to be in intellectual or work environments.
            Two of my friends were making a list of attractive and unattractive traits for a woman to have for their health class.  Number 3 on the list of negative traits was ‘feminist’.  Immediately I tried to explain to them their mistake: feminists are not just the bra-burners (and they never were!).  If you ask me, this should be the first mission for 21st century feminists, BUST THE STEREOTYPE. Make the movement as apparent to the masses, as if it were a coin sitting in the palm of the common hand.
-Julia

Sunday, May 6, 2012

Dialectics: Good Guys and Bad Guys


One cannot expect to turn on the Matrix and be taken through a numbingly predictable plot where it is easy to tell the difference between the bad guys and good guys by who is wearing black and carrying the biggest gun.  Because watching the Matrix isn’t like eating a Twinkie, pleasing to the senses but devoid of any sort of nutrients or substance.  Rather, it feeds the mind like it is a one of those quinoa/wheatgrass/kale/barley superfood smoothies.  Does it make the taste buds beg for more? Absolutely not.  It is hard to swallow and even harder to digest.  But it certainly give your body its daily dose of vitamins, something a Twinkie could never do in its wildest dreams. 
The first time I watched the Matrix I felt miles away from my comfort zone.  I was unsure of what was dream and what was reality, how much ‘science fiction’ and how much pure imagination this movie was.  Reflecting afterwards, I realized in that I had even started off unaware of who the good guys and bad guys were.  Classic ‘good’ and ‘bad’ were often mixed and matched, a being the human that I am I craved a clearly outlined set of rules.  It was clear that Neo was the hero, with his dreamy eyes and general ignorance of what was going on around him.  But towards the beginning the men in suits and the woman in shiny black leather seem equally as deadly. They all have an air of superhuman physical capability and intelligence and they all refuse to take off their dark sunglasses. 
Both sides lack the ability to feel guilt.  They hve a complete disregard for the seriousness of killing another human being.  The Agents do not give a flying squirrel if they were to inflict pain on Morpheus, Neo, or any of the rebels.  In fact, Agent Smith tells Neo that he is going to love watching him die, he is going to take pleasure in killing them.  Is that so different from when Trinity and Neo shoot a seemingly endless string of bullets at the team of security guard, enjoying the feeling of their own awesomeness more than regretting having to kill so many innocent men? The same goes for the beginning of the movie when Trinity kills the team of policemen without breaking a sweat.  Of course, following the premise of the film, all these people are simply projections of their real selves.  But like Nina said in class, just because something’s not real doesn’t mean there is no value, no pain when bullet hits the flesh. How can Neo (who is new to this concept) forget how human pain feels in the Matrix and how human compassionate is supposed to react?
The Good Guy/Bad Guy traits are so intermixed in this film that one of the Good Guys, Cypher, is enticed into betraying his comrades for a life of blissful ignorance.   Cypher is a man who left the Matrix and entered the ‘real world’ with the same convictions as Trinity, Tank and Switch…the same belief that fighting for the truth came before fighting for yourself.  But as the war grew less idealistic and more real, Cypher no longer saw the ‘greater good’ as a priority.  And that is a very human thing, isn’t it?  To betray a quest for some abstract, seemingly unattainable cause for your own well being?  It is part of the human condition to want to save yourself.  In a moment of high stress, even Agent Smith reveals to Morpheus his need to escape from his current state. This seems to fuzz the line between good and evil even further. Is it a good or evil trait to give into this human instinct?
 In general, both Morpheus’ team and the Agent are fighting for what they are taught is the greater good.  On one side, rules are of the utmost necessity: they keep things in order, they keep the system going.  But the other side envisions a world where the rules are bent and broken.  Both sides have superhuman capabilities.  Both sides are willing to go to deadly lengths to achieve their goals. Both sides show vulnerability. Is it so absurd to wonder how the movie would play out if the Agents were trying to free people and Morpheus was using them to feed the machines?  I can’t imagine it would look that much different.

Friday, April 27, 2012

Metacognition: Mashup



If you were to take a glance at the finished project of my mashup you could not imagine the invisible layers that went into creating it.  To think that all a mashup takes is gathering a bunch of quotes and sticking them in a sensible order is to underestimate the complexity of the assignment. Looking at the final project entitled “Love: the ‘right person’ should cause a woman’s independence to flourish, not diminish”,   one could not have any idea that up till a moment before the site was published, the theme was entirely different.

            Initially I chose feminism as the theme for my mashup.  Feminism in Jane Eyre was a constant underlying theme, for Jane was a true 19th century anomaly.  She was a woman who was not afraid to assert herself and challenge men like Rochester, who had not only established himself as superior in gender but in wealth and social status as well. In a world where marriage was often a woman’s ultimate goal, Jane was incredibly ahead of her time.

My first step was to search the entire novel for quotes with a strong feminist intent until I wrung the pages dry.  Looking back, discovering so many quotes deepened my understanding of the theme in relation to Jane Eyre, but it made the process of ‘mashing the elements together’ a slow process.

 A quote said by Mr. Rochester became the impetus for the discovery of my sub-focus.
He said: “What good would it do if I bent, if I uptore, if I crushed her?  Consider that eye: consider the resolute, wild, free thing looking out of it, defying me, with more than courage--with a stern triumph. Whatever I do with its cage, I cannot get at it--the savage, beautiful creature!  If I tear, if I rend the slight prison, my outrage will only let the captive loose.”

            When I discovered this text I realized that this is the kind of love every woman, every feminist should strive for.  Every woman should not settle for a husband [or wife!] who robs them of their independence.  I think that was exactly why Jane turned St. John’s marriage proposal down.  She did not feel free with him! Rather, she felt controlled, constrained, and a little bit frightened of his severe demeanor. 

I had found plenty of outside quotes of women feeling dominated by men and seeking to extricate themselves from that domination (most notably, Maya Angelou’s poem ‘Men’ made the hairs on my arms raise).  But how could I organize the mashup to show how a woman’s independence could be diminished by a controlling man and set free by a true love?  I decided to follow an organizational theme much like how Charlotte Bronte structures the novel: by chronicling the development of Jane’s feminine identity from girlhood to womanhood.  Through this medium, I could show how Jane’s take on love developed with her sense of ‘self’.  This turned out to be a blessing as well as a curse.  I was able to show the true connection between love and a woman’s independence by tracking their developments together… but making separate elements seem like one entity was hard enough without the added challenge of flowing almost like a story.  

The last decision I made on my mashup should really have been the first.  After going through the finished product I realized there was a larger prominence of ‘love’ than ‘feminism’.  Instead of ‘love’ being one aspect of ‘feminism’, ‘feminism’ really was one aspect of ‘love’.  Leaving everything else untouched, I changed nothing the title and soon saw truth in this line in Virginia Woolf’s Orlando: “And when we are writing the life of a woman, we may, it is agreed, waive our demand for action, and substitute love instead. Love, the poet has said, is woman's whole existence.”  In this case, they really were interchangeable.

MY MASHUP: https://sites.google.com/site/juliajacobsacademymashup/

Friday, April 6, 2012

A Midsummer's Night Dream: That Little Extra 'Something'

The full beauty of Shakespeare’s works cannot be contained in book form. Shakespeare is another species of literature where a basic understanding of the English language just doesn’t cut it. To read Shakespeare can be like being asked to dance a pas de deux after a single year of ballet training. You may know the logistics of a pirouette, grande jete, and tourjete. But to dance a strong yet seamless blend of movement is unthinkable without years of drilling, strengthening, and learning to understand where everything comes from. Watching A Midsummer’s Night Dream at the Shakespeare Theatre was like watching Giselle performed by the Joffrey- the actors took the language to a rich, seasoned level by speaking with clarity and emotion. But in this performance there was a little added ‘something’ that translated Shakespeare’s foreign language into something my head and heart could understand. The way they would gesture with, embrace, or simply look at one another was so genuine that I understood without even having to try.

Most impressive was Tracy Michelle Arnold, the actress who played Hippolyta and Titania. From the moment she appeared on stage she astounded me with her power and grace. The way she held her cold silence towards her husband Theseus said more about their relationship and her character than any number of words. As the fairy vixen, she translated brilliantly from challenging Oberon to being caring and motherly towards her servants and the little Changeling Boy. As both characters she enchanted the audience in with her eloquence, not giving any one word favor over another, but letting the intention flow through the language.

In fact dancers must have the same enchanting quality in order to connect with their audience. It’s the difference between watching someone and admiring how smoothly they turn, or how high they jump, and watching someone dance and thinking, “That person is fabulous and I can’t even put my finger out why.” The first weekend of spring break I went to a dance competition with more fake eyelashes, high kicks, and rhinestones than will ever see in my lifetime. But amidst the flurry of bloodthirsty dancers climbing to the top of the heap there were a few word of wisdom from teachers who had been in the business for decades. During one of the workshops a teacher explained that unexplainable quality to us. He said that the connection between performer and audience came from clarity and precision. When every step is intentional, when the audience understands exactly what he/she is trying to accomplish and feels in control and safe.

When Oberon simply walks forward, chest broad and proud, he commands the stage in a way that the audience automatically understands his character. And when Oberon awakes Titania with a potent green plant and a determined kiss, there is no denying his power. That’s not to say that the character has to be bold and commanding to have a connection with the audience. Snug, the actor who plays in the Lion in the ‘play within the play’ is often blubbering and overeager. But his choices are still intentional. Just as Oberon makes us feel confident and in control, Snug makes us laugh and enjoy his character. We laugh when little Peter Quince is swept off the floor by the round and jolly Nick Bottom because the interaction was so brief and underplayed that you felt like you were the only who could’ve caught it… until the whole audience bursts into guffaws.

When the play reached its finish I had a feeling of pure glee. I had been truly swept away by the story of the lovestruck Athenians and diabolical fairies. It was very different from the subdued sort of triumph I feel after trudging through an entire Shakespeare play. Thanks to the actors’ precise understanding of their craft I understood past the words on the page, to the full extent the Bard intended.

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Metacognition: "Things Left Unspoken"

I find that the later into the night I embark on writing, the more bizarre my story becomes. Here is the scene it almost always boils down to: me sitting on the couch with a notebook and pen in my lap, accompanied by parakeets Felix and Alejandro and a half-eaten box of Ritz Bitz Peanut Butter Sandwiches. (Mr. Allen, if you’re reading this, I blame you for any weight I might gain in this story writing process). Once I’m all sobered up and have gotten over the writing hangover the next morning, I might take a look back at the writing I produced and have a drastically different reaction to the ‘brilliance’ I thought I had created at 1 in the morning. In truth, late night/early morning writing is disastrous for plot but can be sublime for character development. I’ve become acquainted with characters from all walks of life, with all sorts of obscure careers and passions, and with varying degrees of sanity. In my short story ‘Things Left Unspoken’ I met Ted, a rapidly aging man whose passion for his wife, Cynthia, slowly faded after four miscarriages. Then there was the nameless stripper working at a casino craps table who would talktalktalk about her problems but never about the solutions. The hardcore plot-line analysis required to create a quality short story had to be done with a clear mind and steady pen.

I knew the whole ending chunk would be dominated my dialogue between Ted and the stripper. My ultimate goal became connecting the two people’s problems so that Ted would find his answer in the strippers’ story. I had absolutely no idea how to do that. I knew it couldn’t be a direct connection because Ted and the stripper were at drastically different places in their life. Ted was suffering from loneliness and lack of purpose, further stirred by the fact that his wife of 27 years had proposed they get divorce. The stripper was suffering a similar sort of purposelessness, but her issue was that she sees no exit from her trashy lifestyle and is resigned to the fact that that her seven year old daughter faces a similar fate.

I considered the common themes I had written into the story as nuances but never actually intended them to be the crux of the ending climax conversation between Ted and the stripper. I had set it up so both characters relied on chance and/or God to give them purpose, both blamed chance or God when that purpose what not achieved. Both chance and God are opposite ends of the spectrum but both require the character to give up trust in themselves and rely on something they have no control over. For example, Ted blames his lack of success in his career on the stocks and Cynthia’s four miscarriages on God. The stripper blames everything on chance, but does not believe in God in the slightest. With that connection made I had to figure out a strategy to make this idea clear to the reader, but not so clear that it feels forced.

As the stripper tells Ted her story with an air of bitterness, Ted grows angrier and angrier. He begins to feel an uncontrollable physical reaction to her words. That is so because I didn’t want it to seem like Ted is all of a sudden this wise, prophet who knew what was right all along. His realization had to be in real time. Finally Ted interrupts the stripper loudly and tells her his realization: she needs to establish her own fate for her and her daughter. While Ted would be telling the stripper to regain faith in herself and choose her own fate, he would be simultaneously telling the same thing to himself. And with that he’d walk off, the reader unsure of how he would apply his realization to his own self-struggle.

Of course, with every piece of work in its earlier drafts there are some unfulfilled questions, some nagging feelings of doubt. Is there a way to fulfill the same realization using action? In other words, is the dialogue too blatant? Too direct? Is it necessary that the readers come out of the story with the exact outcome that I intended? Or is that limiting them from taking away things that I wasn’t even conscious of?

With these nagging questions present in my mind, my Metacognition is sure to continue beyond this blog and into future drafts of the story.

Monday, March 12, 2012

It Matters: The Culture of Women in Beit Shemesh

In discussing feminism in class, we speak about the large, overarching demographic of women. Females of all ages, ethnicities, religions and traditions. We speak of feminism as the universal movement to attain equality between men and women. But we often forget that there are women whose religion in inextricably bound to her femininity. And this complicates their path towards freedom, equality, independence. We often forget that where you live determines so much about how you live. This applies to women especially.

Imagine a woman walking down an American city block in the heat of the summer, wearing an outfit that to her, is both modest and attractive. To her, the ability to walk down that sidewalk wearing whatever she wants is not a privilege, but a right. If she were to be wearing something too tight, too short, and all together too exposing, that too would be her choice. She would not be reprimanded (although she may be hooted and hollered at by especially rude men, it is her choice whether to be offended, flattered, or keep walking as if all she heard was the whine of a lonely hound).

Imagine the same woman walking down a sidewalk in the city of Beit Shemesh, just west of Jerusalem. It is a city filled with ultra-Orthodox Jews and dominated by Jewish law. So dominated by it that the woman might be verbally and physically harassed for wearing clothes that the majority of the world would consider appropriate. This is what repeatedly happened to an eight year-old girl by the name of Naama Margolese late in December 2011. Ultra-orthodox Jewish men spat on Naama, threw rocks at her, shouted at her, called her ‘whore’. Yes, this is an instance of brash extremism. Yes, this is an issue that was dealt with in the right manner: through response from law enforcement and civilian protests. But one man defended this behavior by saying, “The rabbis tell us how a woman should behave when she walks in the street and that’s how it should be.”

Obviously this man’s zealotry leaves no room for understanding gender rights. This man would no sooner ask a woman if her religion is infringing on her freedom as he would follow a chicken salad sandwich with a glass of milk. But because Naama may be too young anyways to be concerned with her identity as a woman, I would love to ask her mother whether her devotion to Judaism supersedes gender equality in all situations. Does she merely tolerate this? Or does she truly believe that the Torah should dictate her identity as a woman?

This control extends beyond just what a woman is allowed to wear walking down the streets. Because contraceptives are banned and large families are traditional, Orthodox Jewish women are expected to bear many children in close succession. In fact when I visited a Hasidic chabad Sabbath service in Florida in December 2011 the young rabbi’s wife had just had her fifth child…and the oldest of her children was six.

To me, that seems to be not only extremely emotionally and physically taxing, but the monopolization of a life not exclusively created for child-rearing. However it’s not far of me to think that all women yearn for the perfect Beyonce-esque balance of power and vulnerability, of independence and motherhood. It may never have be accurate for me to think of women as this strongly united band across the globe. While in theory, this sisterhood is inspiring, it might not work in practice unless women are willing to put the fight for gender equality in front of all else.

Friday, February 10, 2012

Research: "Mommy...where does evil come from?"

Dr. Philip G. Zambardo, director of the Stanford Prison Study produced a detailed overview of his lecture entitled, “Transforming People into Perpetrators of Evil” (see link below). I’ve always wondered what is the best way to study an atrocity: fully charged with emotion? Ready to shock the audience into tears? Or pared down to the most clear, comprehendible points?

After reading Zambardo’s work, I realized that to understand the ‘perpetrator’, one must understand the ‘ABCs’ of why they are committing these heinous crimes. As the basis of the Stanford Prison Study, Zambardo asks, “What happens when we aggregate many of these processes that contribute to the making of Perpetrators: dehumanize victims, deindividuate potential perpetrators, put them in a new strange, anonymous environment, and give the perpetrators total power and render the victims powerless?” In HoD, we can use these points to evaluate and understand Kurtz.

Dehumanizing victims/ rendering them powerless

To Kurtz, his job in the Congo is not to help the lives of the natives progress. It is ivory. When looking from Point A to Point B (Point B being IVORY) Kurtz is blind to any roadblocks. To turn the native people of Congo into savages is the most efficient way for Kurtz to complete his job. That means stealing, killing, enslaving, and destroying, whether by word or by deed. Not to say that the only victims that are being dehumanized are the Congolese. Kurtz dehumanizes the ‘pilgrims’ too. When the harlequin possessed some ivory, Kurtz gave him a choice: give me the ivory or die. As Zambardo says in his report, perpetrators become ‘morally disengaged’ when they have a task to complete.

Deindividuating potential perpetrators

While the word ‘deindividuating’ itself may seem imagined (indeed, I’m getting that red squiggly line under it…), the characteristics are reflected in HoD and embraced by Kurtz in his transformation into evil. The goal is to make people feel anonymous in the hopes that they cross over to the evil side with you. In the ‘grove of death’, where practically everyone is nameless, Kurtz need not worry about people rebelling and sending him off track. The Manager and his Uncle can talk all they want about taking Kurt’s job. But doing something extreme or risky is out of the question for the Manager. All he can do is keep filling out that paperwork, staying as far away from any sort of trouble (i.e. sickly natives) as possible.

Anonymous environment

We discussed how the absence of formal institutions reveals the ‘brute’ in Kurtz. The wilderness affects Kurtz by emptying his soul, lowering the line between GOOD and EVIL, or erasing it altogether. This makes me wonder how different Kurtz was in England. Was he a star-crossed lover, living happily with his Intended? Doubtful. Could he imagine himself committing so many crimes before he departed? I can’t imagine he could have predicted such a thing. Like the transition from comfortable college life, to the guards at a ‘prison’, Kurtz experiences a transition to a place where he is constantly fearing for his own safety. Each time he fell ill, the wilderness grew that much darker, and his capacity for evil that much deeper.

With that in mind, how does a parent explain to a child what ‘evil’ is? How do you they describe the inner workings of the twisted human psyche to a child with wide eyes and an open heart… like an alien who only understands kindness?

Easy answer.

You don’t.

You allow the world to do it for you. Through film, literature, art and history a person can delve into a world of evil and rise unscathed. Reading HoD is immensely different than floating down the River Congo, seeing all that your people have destroyed in your attempts of ‘fixing’ the ‘savages’. Of course, to immerse yourself in the horrors of life second handedly is to leave yourself vulnerable to be deeply affected. I remember reading about Iris Chang, journalist and author of The Rape of Nanking: The Forgotten Holocaust of WWII. Chang became so sleep deprived and disturbed by the content of her work that she committed suicide. Was it because she understood evil all too well? Or because she still couldn’t comprehend how a soldier, a person who was once ignorant of evil, could torture, rape, and murder so many.

LINK: http://www.sonoma.edu/users/g/goodman/zimbardo.htm#prison