Thursday, March 22, 2012

Metacognition: "Things Left Unspoken"

I find that the later into the night I embark on writing, the more bizarre my story becomes. Here is the scene it almost always boils down to: me sitting on the couch with a notebook and pen in my lap, accompanied by parakeets Felix and Alejandro and a half-eaten box of Ritz Bitz Peanut Butter Sandwiches. (Mr. Allen, if you’re reading this, I blame you for any weight I might gain in this story writing process). Once I’m all sobered up and have gotten over the writing hangover the next morning, I might take a look back at the writing I produced and have a drastically different reaction to the ‘brilliance’ I thought I had created at 1 in the morning. In truth, late night/early morning writing is disastrous for plot but can be sublime for character development. I’ve become acquainted with characters from all walks of life, with all sorts of obscure careers and passions, and with varying degrees of sanity. In my short story ‘Things Left Unspoken’ I met Ted, a rapidly aging man whose passion for his wife, Cynthia, slowly faded after four miscarriages. Then there was the nameless stripper working at a casino craps table who would talktalktalk about her problems but never about the solutions. The hardcore plot-line analysis required to create a quality short story had to be done with a clear mind and steady pen.

I knew the whole ending chunk would be dominated my dialogue between Ted and the stripper. My ultimate goal became connecting the two people’s problems so that Ted would find his answer in the strippers’ story. I had absolutely no idea how to do that. I knew it couldn’t be a direct connection because Ted and the stripper were at drastically different places in their life. Ted was suffering from loneliness and lack of purpose, further stirred by the fact that his wife of 27 years had proposed they get divorce. The stripper was suffering a similar sort of purposelessness, but her issue was that she sees no exit from her trashy lifestyle and is resigned to the fact that that her seven year old daughter faces a similar fate.

I considered the common themes I had written into the story as nuances but never actually intended them to be the crux of the ending climax conversation between Ted and the stripper. I had set it up so both characters relied on chance and/or God to give them purpose, both blamed chance or God when that purpose what not achieved. Both chance and God are opposite ends of the spectrum but both require the character to give up trust in themselves and rely on something they have no control over. For example, Ted blames his lack of success in his career on the stocks and Cynthia’s four miscarriages on God. The stripper blames everything on chance, but does not believe in God in the slightest. With that connection made I had to figure out a strategy to make this idea clear to the reader, but not so clear that it feels forced.

As the stripper tells Ted her story with an air of bitterness, Ted grows angrier and angrier. He begins to feel an uncontrollable physical reaction to her words. That is so because I didn’t want it to seem like Ted is all of a sudden this wise, prophet who knew what was right all along. His realization had to be in real time. Finally Ted interrupts the stripper loudly and tells her his realization: she needs to establish her own fate for her and her daughter. While Ted would be telling the stripper to regain faith in herself and choose her own fate, he would be simultaneously telling the same thing to himself. And with that he’d walk off, the reader unsure of how he would apply his realization to his own self-struggle.

Of course, with every piece of work in its earlier drafts there are some unfulfilled questions, some nagging feelings of doubt. Is there a way to fulfill the same realization using action? In other words, is the dialogue too blatant? Too direct? Is it necessary that the readers come out of the story with the exact outcome that I intended? Or is that limiting them from taking away things that I wasn’t even conscious of?

With these nagging questions present in my mind, my Metacognition is sure to continue beyond this blog and into future drafts of the story.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Julia,
    I completely understand where you're coming from with the late night/early morning writing. I've been victim of the whole, "I can do it later, what could possibly go wrong?" mentality FAR too many times before, as I'm sure all us Academy students have. And you're right, while it is great for developing characters, it kind of kills your plot sometimes. Maybe it's because when it's that late/early, we always manage to work completely random, out-of-the-blue ideas into our characters lives, giving them that extra little quirk that makes them more human.
    I like the idea that you had for your story about the similarities between faith in God and chance. It's a nice "side story," for lack of a better term; something else to focus on when you're reading in addition to the main plot and theme.
    Good luck on the final draft of your story, I'm sure it will turn out great! :)

    ReplyDelete