In discussing feminism in class, we speak about the large, overarching demographic of women. Females of all ages, ethnicities, religions and traditions. We speak of feminism as the universal movement to attain equality between men and women. But we often forget that there are women whose religion in inextricably bound to her femininity. And this complicates their path towards freedom, equality, independence. We often forget that where you live determines so much about how you live. This applies to women especially.
Imagine a woman walking down an American city block in the heat of the summer, wearing an outfit that to her, is both modest and attractive. To her, the ability to walk down that sidewalk wearing whatever she wants is not a privilege, but a right. If she were to be wearing something too tight, too short, and all together too exposing, that too would be her choice. She would not be reprimanded (although she may be hooted and hollered at by especially rude men, it is her choice whether to be offended, flattered, or keep walking as if all she heard was the whine of a lonely hound).
Imagine the same woman walking down a sidewalk in the city of Beit Shemesh, just west of Jerusalem. It is a city filled with ultra-Orthodox Jews and dominated by Jewish law. So dominated by it that the woman might be verbally and physically harassed for wearing clothes that the majority of the world would consider appropriate. This is what repeatedly happened to an eight year-old girl by the name of Naama Margolese late in December 2011. Ultra-orthodox Jewish men spat on Naama, threw rocks at her, shouted at her, called her ‘whore’. Yes, this is an instance of brash extremism. Yes, this is an issue that was dealt with in the right manner: through response from law enforcement and civilian protests. But one man defended this behavior by saying, “The rabbis tell us how a woman should behave when she walks in the street and that’s how it should be.”
Obviously this man’s zealotry leaves no room for understanding gender rights. This man would no sooner ask a woman if her religion is infringing on her freedom as he would follow a chicken salad sandwich with a glass of milk. But because Naama may be too young anyways to be concerned with her identity as a woman, I would love to ask her mother whether her devotion to Judaism supersedes gender equality in all situations. Does she merely tolerate this? Or does she truly believe that the Torah should dictate her identity as a woman?
This control extends beyond just what a woman is allowed to wear walking down the streets. Because contraceptives are banned and large families are traditional, Orthodox Jewish women are expected to bear many children in close succession. In fact when I visited a Hasidic chabad Sabbath service in Florida in December 2011 the young rabbi’s wife had just had her fifth child…and the oldest of her children was six.
To me, that seems to be not only extremely emotionally and physically taxing, but the monopolization of a life not exclusively created for child-rearing. However it’s not far of me to think that all women yearn for the perfect Beyonce-esque balance of power and vulnerability, of independence and motherhood. It may never have be accurate for me to think of women as this strongly united band across the globe. While in theory, this sisterhood is inspiring, it might not work in practice unless women are willing to put the fight for gender equality in front of all else.
No comments:
Post a Comment