Friday, February 10, 2012

Research: "Mommy...where does evil come from?"

Dr. Philip G. Zambardo, director of the Stanford Prison Study produced a detailed overview of his lecture entitled, “Transforming People into Perpetrators of Evil” (see link below). I’ve always wondered what is the best way to study an atrocity: fully charged with emotion? Ready to shock the audience into tears? Or pared down to the most clear, comprehendible points?

After reading Zambardo’s work, I realized that to understand the ‘perpetrator’, one must understand the ‘ABCs’ of why they are committing these heinous crimes. As the basis of the Stanford Prison Study, Zambardo asks, “What happens when we aggregate many of these processes that contribute to the making of Perpetrators: dehumanize victims, deindividuate potential perpetrators, put them in a new strange, anonymous environment, and give the perpetrators total power and render the victims powerless?” In HoD, we can use these points to evaluate and understand Kurtz.

Dehumanizing victims/ rendering them powerless

To Kurtz, his job in the Congo is not to help the lives of the natives progress. It is ivory. When looking from Point A to Point B (Point B being IVORY) Kurtz is blind to any roadblocks. To turn the native people of Congo into savages is the most efficient way for Kurtz to complete his job. That means stealing, killing, enslaving, and destroying, whether by word or by deed. Not to say that the only victims that are being dehumanized are the Congolese. Kurtz dehumanizes the ‘pilgrims’ too. When the harlequin possessed some ivory, Kurtz gave him a choice: give me the ivory or die. As Zambardo says in his report, perpetrators become ‘morally disengaged’ when they have a task to complete.

Deindividuating potential perpetrators

While the word ‘deindividuating’ itself may seem imagined (indeed, I’m getting that red squiggly line under it…), the characteristics are reflected in HoD and embraced by Kurtz in his transformation into evil. The goal is to make people feel anonymous in the hopes that they cross over to the evil side with you. In the ‘grove of death’, where practically everyone is nameless, Kurtz need not worry about people rebelling and sending him off track. The Manager and his Uncle can talk all they want about taking Kurt’s job. But doing something extreme or risky is out of the question for the Manager. All he can do is keep filling out that paperwork, staying as far away from any sort of trouble (i.e. sickly natives) as possible.

Anonymous environment

We discussed how the absence of formal institutions reveals the ‘brute’ in Kurtz. The wilderness affects Kurtz by emptying his soul, lowering the line between GOOD and EVIL, or erasing it altogether. This makes me wonder how different Kurtz was in England. Was he a star-crossed lover, living happily with his Intended? Doubtful. Could he imagine himself committing so many crimes before he departed? I can’t imagine he could have predicted such a thing. Like the transition from comfortable college life, to the guards at a ‘prison’, Kurtz experiences a transition to a place where he is constantly fearing for his own safety. Each time he fell ill, the wilderness grew that much darker, and his capacity for evil that much deeper.

With that in mind, how does a parent explain to a child what ‘evil’ is? How do you they describe the inner workings of the twisted human psyche to a child with wide eyes and an open heart… like an alien who only understands kindness?

Easy answer.

You don’t.

You allow the world to do it for you. Through film, literature, art and history a person can delve into a world of evil and rise unscathed. Reading HoD is immensely different than floating down the River Congo, seeing all that your people have destroyed in your attempts of ‘fixing’ the ‘savages’. Of course, to immerse yourself in the horrors of life second handedly is to leave yourself vulnerable to be deeply affected. I remember reading about Iris Chang, journalist and author of The Rape of Nanking: The Forgotten Holocaust of WWII. Chang became so sleep deprived and disturbed by the content of her work that she committed suicide. Was it because she understood evil all too well? Or because she still couldn’t comprehend how a soldier, a person who was once ignorant of evil, could torture, rape, and murder so many.

LINK: http://www.sonoma.edu/users/g/goodman/zimbardo.htm#prison

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Bloggin 'Round: Nina and Lizzie


Nina’s Musings- Metacognition: Get Organized

Nina chose to embark on the great task of organizing her music library, sifting through song after song she had never even listened to. She went from feeling ashamed of her collection (don’t worry Nina, High School Musical is my guilty pleasure too) to proud of it’s eccentricity. She then began to wonder why she was even trying to organize something she would never make use of. Her train of thought rested on the idea she could transform the burden of an overfilled music library into an opportunity for future discovery. It seems that instead of making sense of her playlists, she reorganized her mind so it could breathe easily amidst the clutter.

I wrote:

Hello Nina! First let me say that I found your writing to be delightfully concise, with fresh and language and short journalistic paragraphs that were a treat for my tired eyes! This entry completely embraced the idea of metacognition, it was like a conversation in your mind that I scored front row tickets for.

You wrote about the shame of your friends seeing embarrassing songs on your playlist, insinuating that for it to be on your iPod, you must EAT, SLEEP, and BREATHE the Wiggles.
But as the proud owner of two full Hannah Montana albums I’ve discovered that the only person who is actually judging is myself. Say hello to the pompous music buff sitting on my shoulder, whispering judgments into my ear, “
The Jonas Brothers? Really? So lame. So mainstream. What a lo-o-o-o-ser.”

And so I feverishly hammer at the ‘next’ button until I find something of quality. But like you were saying, the JoBros and Hannah Montana define a point in my life. A time when I was not quite a teen but had worn out being a ‘tween’ . I find that if I force my thumb away from that ‘next button’, I end up singing the words with incredible accuracy into my hairbrush.

I wonder, can you really continue to develop your taste in music with all the clutter of your past?

We know that every song has to become obsolete eventually. But with the iPod, the song is always there, at your immediate grasp. It’s not like a vinyl record, slowly decaying in a forgotten box in the attic. Either it’s there or it’s gone. So maybe you keep those songs. But also, maybe you make a new playlist. One with an emptiness that provides opportunity for years and years of music history.


Lizzie’s Blog- iMedia: Oh, Children

In her iMedia blog, Lizzie digs deep into “Oh, Children” by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds, a song Harry and Hermione danced to in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part II. Lizzie fleshed out the lyrics and the singer’s tone, recognizing a juxtaposition of despair and hope. Nick Cave is calling to the children to ‘rejoice’. He is celebrating life and the happines one feels when they’re willing to accept any path they land on. On the flip side, Lizzie points a dark side: is Nick Cave genuine in his happiness? Or does he yearn for it so much that he has convinced himself and his own mother that he has it?

I wrote: Hello Lizzie! I never saw this song as anything more than pleasing to the ears. I never questioned the reason why it was chosen for HPDHP2… until now!

The juxtaposition of despair and happiness that you wrote about is precisely the atmosphere during that scene in HPDHP2. In the middle of the frigid countryside, abandoned by Ron, Harry and Hermione have no plan of action, not a smidgen of hope. In a moment of pure spontaneity, they dance together. They have a moment of such unburdened joy that you can’t even see the despair lurking behind a corner. While to some, the scene was hokey and unnecessary, I saw it as a beautiful moment to hold on to. Though if I were to follow your train of thought, I’d question the expression on Hermione’s face as she presses it into Harry’s shoulder. Is she content? Or are thoughts of danger and loneliness creeping there way in?

On a non-Harry Potter related note, I wonder if sometimes the anticipation of happiness is even greater than the experience itself? Nick Cave sings, “We're happy ma, we're having fun, and the train ain't even left the station” Is that a happiness for things to come? Or happiness right now, knowing that no matter where the train takes you it will be alright. I think there is so much more depth and quality to the latter feeling. With that, there’s no need to convince anyone that you’re happy because you know that no matter the trials and tribulations, it will be possible to find happiness again. Happiness is a very complex idea to think about, isn’t it? Or maybe it’s simple and we’re doing the ‘human thing’ of blowing it completely out of proportion.

I find that when I’m truly happy, there’s no need to brood over it. But when I feel forlorn or simply bored with life, happiness is completely theoretical. In that state, happiness is an idea to be stretched and squeezed and molded into all different shapes. But in it’s purest form, I worry that questioning happiness will only taint it. Thank you for sparking this, Lizzie!