Friday, April 27, 2012

Metacognition: Mashup



If you were to take a glance at the finished project of my mashup you could not imagine the invisible layers that went into creating it.  To think that all a mashup takes is gathering a bunch of quotes and sticking them in a sensible order is to underestimate the complexity of the assignment. Looking at the final project entitled “Love: the ‘right person’ should cause a woman’s independence to flourish, not diminish”,   one could not have any idea that up till a moment before the site was published, the theme was entirely different.

            Initially I chose feminism as the theme for my mashup.  Feminism in Jane Eyre was a constant underlying theme, for Jane was a true 19th century anomaly.  She was a woman who was not afraid to assert herself and challenge men like Rochester, who had not only established himself as superior in gender but in wealth and social status as well. In a world where marriage was often a woman’s ultimate goal, Jane was incredibly ahead of her time.

My first step was to search the entire novel for quotes with a strong feminist intent until I wrung the pages dry.  Looking back, discovering so many quotes deepened my understanding of the theme in relation to Jane Eyre, but it made the process of ‘mashing the elements together’ a slow process.

 A quote said by Mr. Rochester became the impetus for the discovery of my sub-focus.
He said: “What good would it do if I bent, if I uptore, if I crushed her?  Consider that eye: consider the resolute, wild, free thing looking out of it, defying me, with more than courage--with a stern triumph. Whatever I do with its cage, I cannot get at it--the savage, beautiful creature!  If I tear, if I rend the slight prison, my outrage will only let the captive loose.”

            When I discovered this text I realized that this is the kind of love every woman, every feminist should strive for.  Every woman should not settle for a husband [or wife!] who robs them of their independence.  I think that was exactly why Jane turned St. John’s marriage proposal down.  She did not feel free with him! Rather, she felt controlled, constrained, and a little bit frightened of his severe demeanor. 

I had found plenty of outside quotes of women feeling dominated by men and seeking to extricate themselves from that domination (most notably, Maya Angelou’s poem ‘Men’ made the hairs on my arms raise).  But how could I organize the mashup to show how a woman’s independence could be diminished by a controlling man and set free by a true love?  I decided to follow an organizational theme much like how Charlotte Bronte structures the novel: by chronicling the development of Jane’s feminine identity from girlhood to womanhood.  Through this medium, I could show how Jane’s take on love developed with her sense of ‘self’.  This turned out to be a blessing as well as a curse.  I was able to show the true connection between love and a woman’s independence by tracking their developments together… but making separate elements seem like one entity was hard enough without the added challenge of flowing almost like a story.  

The last decision I made on my mashup should really have been the first.  After going through the finished product I realized there was a larger prominence of ‘love’ than ‘feminism’.  Instead of ‘love’ being one aspect of ‘feminism’, ‘feminism’ really was one aspect of ‘love’.  Leaving everything else untouched, I changed nothing the title and soon saw truth in this line in Virginia Woolf’s Orlando: “And when we are writing the life of a woman, we may, it is agreed, waive our demand for action, and substitute love instead. Love, the poet has said, is woman's whole existence.”  In this case, they really were interchangeable.

MY MASHUP: https://sites.google.com/site/juliajacobsacademymashup/

No comments:

Post a Comment