Sunday, May 6, 2012

Dialectics: Good Guys and Bad Guys


One cannot expect to turn on the Matrix and be taken through a numbingly predictable plot where it is easy to tell the difference between the bad guys and good guys by who is wearing black and carrying the biggest gun.  Because watching the Matrix isn’t like eating a Twinkie, pleasing to the senses but devoid of any sort of nutrients or substance.  Rather, it feeds the mind like it is a one of those quinoa/wheatgrass/kale/barley superfood smoothies.  Does it make the taste buds beg for more? Absolutely not.  It is hard to swallow and even harder to digest.  But it certainly give your body its daily dose of vitamins, something a Twinkie could never do in its wildest dreams. 
The first time I watched the Matrix I felt miles away from my comfort zone.  I was unsure of what was dream and what was reality, how much ‘science fiction’ and how much pure imagination this movie was.  Reflecting afterwards, I realized in that I had even started off unaware of who the good guys and bad guys were.  Classic ‘good’ and ‘bad’ were often mixed and matched, a being the human that I am I craved a clearly outlined set of rules.  It was clear that Neo was the hero, with his dreamy eyes and general ignorance of what was going on around him.  But towards the beginning the men in suits and the woman in shiny black leather seem equally as deadly. They all have an air of superhuman physical capability and intelligence and they all refuse to take off their dark sunglasses. 
Both sides lack the ability to feel guilt.  They hve a complete disregard for the seriousness of killing another human being.  The Agents do not give a flying squirrel if they were to inflict pain on Morpheus, Neo, or any of the rebels.  In fact, Agent Smith tells Neo that he is going to love watching him die, he is going to take pleasure in killing them.  Is that so different from when Trinity and Neo shoot a seemingly endless string of bullets at the team of security guard, enjoying the feeling of their own awesomeness more than regretting having to kill so many innocent men? The same goes for the beginning of the movie when Trinity kills the team of policemen without breaking a sweat.  Of course, following the premise of the film, all these people are simply projections of their real selves.  But like Nina said in class, just because something’s not real doesn’t mean there is no value, no pain when bullet hits the flesh. How can Neo (who is new to this concept) forget how human pain feels in the Matrix and how human compassionate is supposed to react?
The Good Guy/Bad Guy traits are so intermixed in this film that one of the Good Guys, Cypher, is enticed into betraying his comrades for a life of blissful ignorance.   Cypher is a man who left the Matrix and entered the ‘real world’ with the same convictions as Trinity, Tank and Switch…the same belief that fighting for the truth came before fighting for yourself.  But as the war grew less idealistic and more real, Cypher no longer saw the ‘greater good’ as a priority.  And that is a very human thing, isn’t it?  To betray a quest for some abstract, seemingly unattainable cause for your own well being?  It is part of the human condition to want to save yourself.  In a moment of high stress, even Agent Smith reveals to Morpheus his need to escape from his current state. This seems to fuzz the line between good and evil even further. Is it a good or evil trait to give into this human instinct?
 In general, both Morpheus’ team and the Agent are fighting for what they are taught is the greater good.  On one side, rules are of the utmost necessity: they keep things in order, they keep the system going.  But the other side envisions a world where the rules are bent and broken.  Both sides have superhuman capabilities.  Both sides are willing to go to deadly lengths to achieve their goals. Both sides show vulnerability. Is it so absurd to wonder how the movie would play out if the Agents were trying to free people and Morpheus was using them to feed the machines?  I can’t imagine it would look that much different.

2 comments:

  1. Great blog- I loved the superfood smoothie comparison. I, too, believe that in pop culture and kids movies, we are trained to see people as wholly good or wholly bad. It's why we as a class had so much trouble determining the morality of Kurtz from "Heart of Darkness." I believe that good and bad is more like a spectrum than anything, because we only define goodness based on whether or not an action, thought, or idea is supported by morals which we have previously adopted. For instance, a person could say that giving money to homeless people on the street is good because they believe that they have a duty to help those in need. Another person would see it in the opposite way; that by giving money, you are enabling a mentally ill person to buy drugs and alcohol and harming his/her health. In addition to this, the god guy/bad guy notion breaks down because even the best people do bad things. Neo and Trinity killed the security guards even though they seem to be portrayed as good. This is what makes certain movies so thought-provoking and hard to process; we want to justify and agree with every action the protagonist takes, and when we can't do this, we are forced to stretch our brains and evaluate whether or not the cause really is a noble one.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Julia - Twinkies do lack a lot of nutrition. Mr. Smith also seems to be crunchy and bland in nature. Your question is an important one - why is everyone so callous in The Matrix, both in the program, and in the real-world? When we think about the Matrix as a program, in the world of simulated reality, we know people have feelings within this world. This world might be like our own. Yet why don’t Neo or Mr. Smith share these feelings?

    The lack of Cypher’s knowledge of the ‘greater good’, as you point out, may point to a psychological effect of the Matrix on people. When one is in the Matrix, they appear psychologically sane and normal (with some exceptions, e.g. Neo). When they leave the Matrix, they become callous, and lose perspective for what is around them, and their missions to liberate certain humans seem to defy ethics, as you’ve explained.

    This seems to stem from an important principle which The Matrix uncovers: that our perception of the world fuels our values. If we were to know of the Matrix’ existence in a world where what we perceived as real wasn’t (the Matrix world), we might think different about ethics.

    Nonetheless, this is an important experiment, and can be applied elsewhere, including to the real-world (which we can hopefully show to not be in a Matrix or part of a Matrix). For an isolated African village without a cell phone, technology, or even a simple machine such as plow, life, values, and language are different. When inventions and innovations such as these are introduced, they fundamentally alter the system of values within the Matrix (or within that African community). This conclusion is surprising. The Matrix touches something very deep here, which you recognize - that the Matrix (a metaphor for what we might call technology in our world) changes belief systems and values - sometimes for the worse.

    ReplyDelete