For the past week I have walked out of period 4 a dark, solemn, almost numb version of myself. I weave through faceless obstacles with a weight on my back that is much more than my school supplies. I sit. I chew. I swallow and digest until energy floods back into my bloodstream... reality into my mind. Or it is reality? I wonder which situation is less manipulated by media: sitting in the cafeteria, eating apricot yogurt and a leftover piece of kugel, surrounded by either over- or under-enthusiastic teenagers shoving social norms down my throat? Or, sitting in my period 4 Intro to Broadcasting class, where I’m drowned in the exploited controversy and tragedy in ‘Bowling for Columbine’, a documentary by Michael Moore.
Excuse my melodrama, but that seems to be the only way you can get a point across these days. Drugs, sex, money, and guns. Check all that apply. And Moore did just that. However he paid special attention to one of the four. He sought to expose the reason for the abundance of violence and homicide in America compared to other first world countries. Quite obviously, he sought to justify a reason he already believed to be truth: gun obsession.
Moore had given us a set of statistics on gun-related deaths per year in a handful of major countries. United Kingdom- 68. France-225. Australia- 65. You know it’s coming. Canada- 165. You think to yourself, “Aha! He can’t fool me! He’s going to lead it all up to the end where America will have, like… double what these countries have! I see what he’s doing here.” Japan- 39. Germany- 381. The Unites States of America- 11, 127.
A number, by itself, means little. But this number, so drastically different from all the others, grabs you by the shirt collar and YANKS you over to Moore’s side of the argument. His argument states that youth’s exposure to guns, the government’s war decisions, and media’s glamorization of violence (among other things) is creating a society where tragedies like Columbine are to be expected. Many who side with Moore, like shock-rocker Marilyn Manson, believe widespread fear is to blame. Many Americans pack heat because they belief that is the best way to protect their families, and their responsibility as an American citizen. Manson wonders why it is his image they are afraid of, rather than President Bush, who happened to be bombing Kosovo like no other the day of Columbine.
Charleston Heston, former president of the National Rifle Association, would never admit this fear. Because when punches a rifle into the air and bellows, “From my cold, dead hands!”, you know his type. He has an opinion that has defined him entirely. And he will go to infinity and beyond to defend this opinion, even if it means sticking to fallacies like, “I keep my gun loaded because the 2nd Amendment says that it is my right”. How can this be enough for him, and for so many others who stick to this prerogative? Are they ignorant of the consequences of this gun-obsession? Are they ignorant of the 11,127? What about gun manufacturers? How do they properly justify a gun in the hands of two disturbed teenage boys, or in that of the neglected 6 year old child who killed a classmate back in 2000? They can formulate a quaint little answer all they want, but would they ever tell the public the real answer? Money! The argument comes full circle and we revisit one of the four melodramas of our nation.
The reason I was so numb after watching ‘Bowling for Columbine’ was not because my innocent suburban-nurtured mind couldn’t handle the drugs, sex, money, and guns. It was because I was being bombarded with disturbing fact after fact coupled with jaw-dropping image after image, and there was no reassurance. At the clang of the bell, Mr. Ferguson would stop the movie and tell us to “have a great day”. There was no closure, no ghost of Eric Harris or Dylan Klebold to say they’re sorry and tell us that nothing like Columbine would ever happen again. None of Moore’s central questions, none of my own questions stated above were answered, because it was proven that it is too much for some people to consider different ways of life. Of course, that isn’t always their fault. The concept of pride has been engrained in them since youth. The pride of living ‘the one right way’ while everyone else is wrong is tempting to many, but I have come to the conclusion that the key is to adhere a culture that constantly reconsiders its ideals in order to keep up with an ever-changing world with an increasingly available supply of weapons.
this made me think... thank you for that. LOVE YOU JULIA!!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteJulia,
ReplyDeleteCan I just say how much I love your blog? Seriously, your writing rocks my world! I feel like your words are jumping off of the page, grabbing a brush and a canvas, and painting a beautiful picture right before my eyes. I absolutely love it.
Anyways, this post really got me thinking. Though I had been aware that gun violence was very prevalent in America, I had no clue how high it was in comparison to other countries who live in similar situations like us.
I think you're right when you say that money is a hugely driving factor in gun manufacturing/ gun associations, but I also don't think that these people are cold-hearted enough to not bat an eyelash at these staggering numbers. I think they are aware of the amount of violence that is caused by guns annually, they do after-all work with guns for a living so gun-related numbers are probably thrown their way left and right.
This may be a little too optimistic but I think that maybe the reason they stick to their guns so ardently (no pun intended) and justify what they do is because they're ashamed.
I know that seems a little bit ridiculous, but think about it- you do this thing for a living that is causing so many people to get hurt. People will most likely bring that fact to your attention maybe out of anger, or sorrow, or plain matter-of-factness. You're going to feel guilty once the facts hit you, but from what I know about human beings,most of the time you won't admit to it out-loud. You may feel all the shame in the world,but that will just make you want to justify yourself even more because as much as people don't like feeling ashamed, they probably don't like harsh judgement either . It just makes them feel even worse about themselves. By staving off these accusations, they can shelter their thoughts from the cruel truth being thrown at them and carry on with their lives.
I can completely relate when you say one of the things that bothered you was the lack of reassurance. Reassurance is kind of my middle name so I definitely know where you're coming from when you say that it almost haunted you, all the unanswered questions hitting the walls of your head like a bee trapped under a cup.
Though the documentary you watched may have been disturbing, the fact that your wrote a blog post about it is proof that the message made an impact on you. Sometimes that's what it takes to get the attention of people, extreme exposure of the truth or other shocking media to make you realize what's going on. It maybe be tough to swallow but it definitely made a statement which is exactly what the makers of documentaries like this aim to do.
Overall, I really liked your thoughts. Your voice was very you, I could picture you saying all this to me as if we were out to coffee, or sitting in the acad room. Thank you for the insightful read!